Comments on: Top down or bottom up politics? http://mauvyrusset.com/2008/12/31/top-down-or-bottom-up-politics/ User Experience, the Universe and Everything Sat, 29 May 2010 11:51:12 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.com/ By: Scott Parsons http://mauvyrusset.com/2008/12/31/top-down-or-bottom-up-politics/#comment-229 Scott Parsons Fri, 05 Jun 2009 21:14:22 +0000 http://mauvyrusset.com/?p=57#comment-229 Richard, I once heard politics defined as "the acquisition and retention of power". While I agree with your view of "how things should be", it seems unlikely. One interesting exception was Brad Blanton's 2004 US congressional campaign (look him up in Wikipedia) which he ran with from a "Radical Honesty" perspective. He always told the truth to every question he was ever asked. He got some traction, but lost in the end. -Scott (yes, the one who works with you!) Richard,

I once heard politics defined as “the acquisition and retention of power”. While I agree with your view of “how things should be”, it seems unlikely. One interesting exception was Brad Blanton’s 2004 US congressional campaign (look him up in Wikipedia) which he ran with from a “Radical Honesty” perspective. He always told the truth to every question he was ever asked. He got some traction, but lost in the end.

-Scott (yes, the one who works with you!)

]]> By: David Harper http://mauvyrusset.com/2008/12/31/top-down-or-bottom-up-politics/#comment-160 David Harper Tue, 13 Jan 2009 13:37:06 +0000 http://mauvyrusset.com/?p=57#comment-160 I would suggest that a Top Down prediliction can be seen in nearly every decision that people make about many things in life, not just political parties. Many people will purchase something based purely on the fact that it looks good rather than it performs well, or better than its competitiors. Notable examples include iPods and cars. Until possibly very recently when energy costs have rocketed to new heights, most people would have based their automotive buying decision on what looked good, not what had the best MPG or its mechanical excellence. The same with the iPod example. I am not saying there is anything wrong with them, just that most people wouldn't spend the time to research other makes and weigh up their individual merits, they would simply choose the iPod based on image alone. Politicians know this is how the majority of people think and are therefore willing to spend great amounts of time massaging their polical 'brands' rather than focussing purely on what the people want. David Harper Managing Director PresentWise Ltd www.presentwise.co.uk I would suggest that a Top Down prediliction can be seen in nearly every decision that people make about many things in life, not just political parties. Many people will purchase something based purely on the fact that it looks good rather than it performs well, or better than its competitiors. Notable examples include iPods and cars. Until possibly very recently when energy costs have rocketed to new heights, most people would have based their automotive buying decision on what looked good, not what had the best MPG or its mechanical excellence. The same with the iPod example. I am not saying there is anything wrong with them, just that most people wouldn’t spend the time to research other makes and weigh up their individual merits, they would simply choose the iPod based on image alone. Politicians know this is how the majority of people think and are therefore willing to spend great amounts of time massaging their polical ‘brands’ rather than focussing purely on what the people want.

David Harper
Managing Director
PresentWise Ltd
http://www.presentwise.co.uk

]]>